Insights into Psychology

What Is… Self-Esteem

Insights into Psychology: Self-esteem: what it is and what it isn't

In this series, I dig a little deeper into the meaning of psychology-related terms. This week’s term is self-esteem.

Self-esteem refers to the extent to which we perceive the various elements of our self-concept positively. It incorporates our physical self-image, how we feel about the things we’ve accomplished, how successful we consider ourselves to be at the things that are important to us, and how we feel about how others view and interact with us. It’s not something you simply have or you don’t; rather, it’s a subjective appraisal of all of those various elements. It’s not necessarily stable over time, and it’s something we have the power to change.

A commonly used measurement tool is the Rosenberg Self-Esteem Scale.

Related constructs

There are various psychological constructs that are similar but distinct. Understanding what self-esteem is not can make it clearer what it is. Some of these related concepts include:

  • self-acceptance: understanding one’s self, including strengths and weaknesses, and accepting the whole package, warts and all
  • self-compassion: this is about how we treat ourselves, and recognizing that we are fallible humans that are deserving of kindness and forgiveness simply by virtue of being human; a positive view of the self can make it easier to practice self-compassion, but isn’t necessary
  • self-concept: the perception of who you are, and what makes you, you
  • self-confidence: our belief in our ability to handle ourselves in the situations we find ourselves in, including problem-solving and dealing with challenges that arise
  • self-doubt: feelings of uncertainty about some aspects of the self; some extent of self-doubt is very normal and can help to keep us realistic, and it can co-exist alongside self-esteem
  • self-efficacy: this is more specific than self-confidence, and is a sense of being able to get ‘er done when it comes to particular types of tasks
  • self-image: this is sort of like the judgy form of self-concept, and often, it isn’t very well grounded in reality
  • self-love: an authentic appreciation of the self that’s more enduring than self-compassion, which can be practiced in how we treat ourselves at particular points in time; a deficit of self-love can contribute to poor boundaries and codependency
  • self-importance: rating one’s own importance/value as higher than others; someone can view themselves positively without seeing themselves as being above others, but someone can also have very high self-importance that’s underpinned by a negative appraisal of the self
  • self-worth: this is similar to self-esteem, in that it relates to how we value ourselves, but it takes a bigger picture perspective, seeing ourselves as valuable, worthy human beings in the world

Contributing factors

Childhood factors, including home environment, poverty, and lack of praise, affection and encouragement, can have a big impact. Failing to meet the expectations of others, including family and peer groups, can also contribute to low self-esteem.

Self-criticism, inflexible rules and standards, anxious predictions, and avoidance can all have a negative impact. PsychologyTools has a great vicious flower diagram of some of these self-perpetuating thought patterns.

Social media use tends to decrease self-esteem (no surprise there). It encourages comparisons which are often unrealistic because so many people are presenting a carefully selected side of themselves.

Low self-esteem is a common issue in various mental disorders, including depression. The grandiosity seen in narcissistic personality disorder is often built on a foundation of negative perceptions of the self, and high esteem is sought from others to compensate. However, finding one’s tribe and accessing peer support can be a good thing, so a lot has to do with how you use it.

How to boost it

Psychologists have identified various ways to boost self-esteem, including:

  • setting realistic goals
  • not being perfectionistic—of course, easier said than done, but accepting mistakes and imperfections is actually better for your mental wellbeing than striving for perfection
  • minimize comparison to others (speaking of easier said than done…)
  • being willing to adapt self-image as the self evolves over time (this is an especially important point when it comes to dealing with the effects of chronic illness)
  • meditation can help with creating distance from the inner turbulence that’s bound to come up every so often
  • using realistic affirmations (unrealistic, rainbows and unicorns-style affirmations can often just make negative appraisals of the self even worse)
  • identify and develop your competencies and remind yourself of your achievements
  • work on accepting compliments
  • practice self-compassion rather than self-criticism

Cognitive behavioural therapy can be useful in reappraising some of the distorted thoughts and thinking patterns that can feed into low self-esteem. Behavioural experiments can help with challenging predictions and addressing avoidance behaviours.

Implications of self-esteem level

Self-esteem can influence how we attribute positive or negative outcomes. Someone who views themselves positively is more likely to attribute positive outcomes to them having done things well, while negative outcomes tend to be attributed, at least in part, to external factors. For someone who views themselves negatively, positive outcomes are more likely to be attributed externally, while negative outcomes are attributed internally.

In adolescents, higher self-esteem has been linked to boys having more confidence to initiate sex and girls having more confidence to set boundaries around sex. Self-esteem, body image, and eating disorder risk are often tied up in a big messy knot in adolescent girls.

People with healthy self-esteem tend to be less critical of themselves and others, less likely to feel shame and guilt, more resilient, and better able to handle stress, be assertive, and set boundaries effectively in relationships.

If you worry about high self-esteem potentially making you a bad person, that’s unlikely to be the case, as long as there’s balance with some of the other related concepts. Healthy self-esteem and healthy self-doubt can happily coexist and keep you realistic about your strengths and weaknesses (and we all have plenty of both). If it’s paired with high self-importance, that’s more likely to cause interpersonal challenges, but healthy self-esteem and high self-importance don’t really like to hang out together.

Getting personal

I remember the last time I was in hospital, which was after a suicide attempt, one of the psychiatrists was certain that I needed to work on my self-esteem. When I told him that wasn’t an issue, he didn’t believe me, because he didn’t think there would be any other reason for me to attempt suicide. It puzzled me that he couldn’t see that not wanting to live because illness made life too shitty had nothing to do with how I felt about myself. I’m good with myself. I’m rather weird, and I’m far from perfect, but I’m totally good with that. My illness is shitty, but it’s an illness I have, not something that I see as being an indicator of something fundamentally wrong with me.

How is your own self-esteem? Does it ever get tangled up with any of the related by different concepts?

This Improving Self-Esteem workbook is from the Centre for Clinical Interventions.

Sources

The Psychology Corner: Insights into psychology and psychological tests

The Psychology Corner has an overview of terms covered in the What Is… series, along with a collection of scientifically validated psychological tests.

29 thoughts on “What Is… Self-Esteem”

  1. Thank you for this post – it’s very enlightening. What I found particularly interesting was the mention that social media can make self-esteem worse through always comparing ourselves to others when what they are posting has already been filtered through the rose colored glasses lens. Thanks so much for sharing!

  2. My self-esteem has been pretty low since adolescence, maybe earlier. Getting my autism diagnosis earlier this year has really helped, though, inasmuch as I can now see myself as an autistic person who is trying hard with some success rather than a neurotypical person who is frequently failing for no obvious reason.

  3. In military survival training, they taught us there are four things a person needs to survive. The first three are physical, food and water, protection from excessive heat and cold, the ability to excrement waste ( believe it or not constipation can become a serious problem in wilderness survival). The fourth thing is not physical, self esteem. A person with no self esteem can not survive.

  4. This is a powerful post! I think, for me, it requires some more observation as to how I handle certain things. I especially need to look at the results of positive or negative self-esteem in me, to determine how big of an issue this is.

  5. Mine varies. Today it’s low for various reasons. I feel physically terrible even for me (normal this time of year but still). I keep BLAMING myself for any little thing that goes wrong at work when in reality it’s rarely my fault. I feel like other people simply have a way better grasp on life than I do. I just can’t get anything done important accomplished and realistically, I never will given my age. I’m just existing day to day in order to feed my cat…

  6. How is your own self-esteem? Does it ever get tangled up with any of the related by different concepts?

    My self esteem is low. It’s higher than it has ever been in my entire life though and that’s a bit of progress. I’ll never embrace ‘self love’, but I am coming to at least accept who I am, warts and all. There was far too much negative reinforcement that I got as a child and teenager that in my opinion permanently damaged my view of self. I still feel unworthy, unlovable, ugly, stupid and a host of other negative voices that shout when something is going wrong in my life. I take too much blame for things that aren’t my fault and have nothing to do with me either. It’s tricky, this self esteem business.

    I was always what I thought others wanted me to be, and when everyone who told me who I was, was dead or out of my life, I had to admit that I didn’t ‘see’ myself at all.

    At least now I can see me, and while I’ll never be totally satisfied with what I see, I can accept it to a degree. That’s huge and it’s helped a lot with my other mental illness issues too.

  7. Is self-esteem still being emphasized? We were under the impression that self-esteem as a psychological concept peaked in the 90s—everyone gets a participation trophy—and was now in the dog house.

    We think Kristin Neff has a video about how boosting self-esteem relies on extrinsic factors and, therefore, self-esteem is not a focus of her psychological healing model. Self-compassion instead, she says, is the intrinsic and more effective barometer of psychological health and resiliency, or something like that.

    1. I remember Kristin Neff saying that in the book Self-Compassion. I didn’t entirely understand her line of reasoning then, and I still don’t, because I disagree with her that self-esteem relies on extrinsic factors. In fact, I think external factors play a minimal role in healthy self-esteem. I don’t think the everyone gets a participation trophy approach was ever an effective way of building genuine self-esteem, as it still emphasizes external rather than internal appraisals. Healthy self-esteem comes from viewing oneself positively whether one wins or loses, not from token pretending that everyone wins and no one loses.

      What I do agree with Kristin Neff on is that self-esteem is not a requirement for self-compassion, and if one’s goal is building self-compassion, working on self-esteem would be at most indirect pathway to achieving that goal.

      1. She’d probably agree that healthy self-esteem would discount external factors but she seemed to argue that isn’t aligned with most people’s practices. We think her point was that most people’s self-esteem is and will continue to be affected by comparison.

        So possibly she is arguing for abandonment of self-esteem building in favor of self-compassion building.

  8. My self-esteem is a fragile thing. I think this is true with people who struggle with eating disorders. It’s part of the package. I find my self-esteem is best when I’m alone. The world has a very negative effect. Overly sensitive to others, overly sensitive to criticism, a fragile appreciation of my accomplishments? Who knows? I do know that for me, like others, self-compassion is an important component. Self-efficacy too. I feel particularly shit when I’m not getting anything done.

  9. A quality post Ashley – l am currently in the throes of trying to motivate Suzanne, who is suffering from a lowered issue of self esteem and ‘purpose and point’ in life.

  10. Isn’t it annoying when professionals assume they know your mental state better than you do or that they know what you are going through. I don’t think I have a low self-esteem but I do struggle with self-confidence and sometimes it’s hard to differentiate the two.

Leave a Reply