Book Reviews

Book Review: Safe: A Memoir

book cover: Safe by Elspeth Roake

In Safe: A Memoir, Elspeth Roake shares her journey with depression and trauma-related disordered attachment, from the lowest lows to finally finding healing.

Elspeth competed in horse shows, and the book begins in Florida for the winter show season, with her going into the hospital for suicidal ideation. She ended up being Baker Acted (committed involuntarily), and was forced to undergo a cavity search when she arrived on the psych unit.

After she’s discharged, the book then moves 2 years back in time. Elspeth’s boss Leslie plays a major role in the book, and was Elspeth’s main source of support. She writes:

I’m not good with boundaries, and Leslie doesn’t have any, so in some ways, she was the perfect mentor for me. In the long run, it didn’t set me up for very good relationship skills, but I didn’t realize this until much later. I continuously emailed and called, and eventually texted, once that was invented. She is my boss, but over the years, she has also become my best friend and my life coach. And now she is, in my mind, the one person who can fix everything.

At one point, Elspeth realized that she needed to work on her mental health, and put together her own program for this. She shares some of the reading that she did that resonated with her, including Bessel van der Kolk’s The Body Keeps the Score.

She set high goals for herself, including doing an Ironman, but offers the insight, “I have succeeded. I also realize I have failed. I am the same person I was before I completed the Ironman. If anything, I am more depressed, and feel even more psychological pain.”

Cutting was a major coping mechanism, and the book explores her state of mind while cutting. Elspeth admits, “I’ll always be a cutter, active or not. It’s who I am.” Even when she was in therapy, the cutting continued, and her story is a good example of how cutting is unlikely to stop unless there are new, more adaptive coping mechanisms that are effective enough to take the place of cutting.

Suicide also comes up repeatedly in the book, and is discussed honestly and openly.

The book offers really interesting insight into what it’s like to have disordered attachment. One of the things she had a hard time with was object permanence, i.e. knowing that things still exist even when they’re not in front of you. It’s interesting to observe her relationship with Leslie. Elspeth says that “When she is gone, safety simply doesn’t exist” (hence the title Safe). While Elspeth mentions that she doesn’t meet the full criteria for borderline personality disorder, her relationship with Leslie gives the reader some insight into the favourite person dynamic in BPD.

After the hospitalization that occurred at the start of the book, Elspeth manages to find a therapist who was able help her make real progress with recovery. That part of the story is compressed at the end of the book, so in a way it seems like it happened quickly, although clearly that kind of healing work never happens quickly. It sounds like she was able to make tremendous progress compared to the lows she shared with the reader.

For me, what really stood out in this book was the exploration of attachment issues. The author is very open about her state of mind, and nothing is glossed over because it might be embarrassing. She’s able to articulate her thoughts and emotions very well, and from what appears to be a place of non-judgment. This book makes for a very interesting read.

Safe is available on Amazon.

I received a free copy in exchange for an honest review.

You can find my other book reviews here.

book cover: Managing the Depression Puzzle by Ashley L. Peterson

Managing the Depression Puzzle takes a holistic look at the different potential pieces that might fit into your unique depression puzzle. It’s available on Amazon and other online retailers, as well as the MH@H Store.

This post contains affiliate links, which let you support MH@H at no extra cost to you.

16 thoughts on “Book Review: Safe: A Memoir”

    1. Thank God they didn’t put me through a cavity search when I was hospitalized! The part where you have to get naked so they can check to see if you have any marks/cuts/bruises when you are being admitted was bad enough!

    2. I too was threatened with this treatment. When I was Baker Acted after a dissociative episode, the nurse threatened to strip me of my clothes and handcuff me to tbe hospital bedif I didn’t start compling quicker with their orders. I was confused and in fear waking up in the hospital with no memory as to how I got there. It was terrible. This book and Ashleyleia’s review shine alight on how people are wrongly treated in the mwntalhealrh system.

  1. Wow, I can relate to so muchofwhat you shared. Unfortunately the awful and horrifying treatment here in the state of Florida’s mental hospitals. A state that is quick to Baker Act. I believe her bookshelves as a powerful testimony and source of inspiration. Thank you for reviewing it and sharing it here Ashleyleia🙏

      1. Yes, this is reoccurring theme I have found in many other’s stories. I have lived in many other states and each one is different yet Florida’s MHS is one of the worst.

  2. It can be difficult to be the favourite person, I regret bungling boundaries terribly with my former friend R. I often carry guilt that I didn’t know how to say no and kept giving even when I was reprimanded at work.

    I wonder if the book explains how they managed to maintain the relationship? I had to leave R for other non FP reasons, but I feel I could have handled being the FP better.

    Also a cavity search sounds absolutely horrific and dehumanising. I think psych wards can really give certain people huge power trips.

    Oh god

    1. Yeah, for sure. It sounds like the author’s FP had the patience of a saint, not just in that relationship, but in general. Not many people are as skilled as the FP sounds like she was.

Leave a Reply