Not long ago, a photo was forwarded to Time.com from a 2001 yearbook of Canadian prime minister Justin Trudeau, who was a teacher at the time, dressed in an Aladdin costume that included brownface makeup. It caused quite a stir, with some people criticizing him as being racist.
Since it’s Halloween, it seems like a good time to talk about blackface/brownface makeup as well as the idea of cultural appropriation.
To start off, it’s worth noting that I am white, and have an undeniable level of privilege because of that. I grew up in a small Canadian town that was mostly white, with some South Asian, Indigenous, and a few assorted other folks tossed in for good measure. I now live in a large Canadian city that is quite multicultural and multi-ethnic, but in relative terms has a very small population of Black people.
To be perfectly honest, it’s only been in the last couple of years that I’ve even heard the issue brought up about how offensive blackface is, and learned about its disturbing origins. Wikipedia says:
Yikes. For most of my life, I didn’t have the slightest clue about any of that. It’s not a matter of willful ignorance, either; I just simply had never been exposed to that information.
If I look back to 2001, when I was in my early 20’s and living in the same city Justin Trudeau was, if someone had shown up at a Halloween party I was attending wearing blackface as part of, say, a Jackson Five costume, I would have thought that person was just going full-out getting into costume, and not given it a second thought.
Would I consider that okay now? No. Looking through the lens I have now, I see why it’s offensive. From the lens I had then, I would’ve had no idea. Does that mean I was racist then? I don’t think so. Was I clueless? Sure. Was I clueless because of my white privilege? Probably.
But cluelessness without any exposure to corrective information doesn’t make someone racist. On the other hand, receiving corrective information and then choosing to ignore it is probably a fairly good indicator of racism.
What seems less clear to me is the idea of cultural appropriation as it pertains to Halloween costumes. I’m really not sure how much my views on this are shaped by the privilege of being a member of the dominant culture, and also by my perspective that going too far with political correctness doesn’t end up sending the positive message that it’s supposed to, and if anything may weaken it.
My feeling on it is this – Halloween costumes are all about caricature, and pretending to be someone you’re not for one night. There’s often a twist of ridiculous, along with a hearty helping of offensiveness. Whether it’s as simple as the sexy nurse or nun, or a more extreme example like the “mental patient” in a straightjacket, Halloween often involves taking extreme stereotypes and then ratcheting up the extremeness to whole new levels.
While some people dressing up as someone of another race or culture may have racist or other biased views, I think a lot of people do not. Poor taste, sure, but that’s pretty pervasive on Halloween. I’m not convinced that automatically translates into espousing those particular stereotypes the other 364 days of the year.
It reminds me somewhat of mental illness stigma, where stereotypes get attached to labels, but simply changing the words isn’t going to make the stigma go away. Similarly, racial and cultural stereotypes may be linked to certain types of costumes or physical characteristics, but doing away with the costumes and the makeup isn’t going to make the underlying prejudice go away. And it’s that deep, underlying prejudice that results in the most harm.
That being said, I recognize that minority cultural groups do get offended by this, and that needs to be respected, as it matters far more than whatever the “they” of political correctness have to say.
Still, I think there are probably better ways to focus our attention. There seem to be a lot of racist, hateful, angry white men running around in the U.S. right now (and other places, for that matter), and I think they pose a far greater threat than people who dressed up in brownface 20 years ago and white kids wearing Black Panther character costumes this Halloween.